DUI with BAL over .15 in Florida

Under Florida law, the legal limit for driving under the influence is a breath or blood alcohol level or concentration is 0.08.

The number “.08” for Florida’s legal per se limit refers to grams of alcohol per specific volume of biological fluid:

  • >0.08 grams of ethyl alcohol per 210 liters of deep lung (alveolar) breath; or 
  • 0.08 grams of ethyl alcohol in 100 milliliters of whole blood.

When applied to enhanced penalties under F.S. § 316.193(4):

  • .15 BAC = 0.15 grams of alcohol per 210 liters of breath; or
  • .15 BAL = 0.15 grams of alcohol per 100 milliliters of blood.

Blowing an alcohol concentration of .15 or higher—nearly double the legal limit—triggers enhanced criminal penalties under Florida Statute § 316.193(4), including mandatory ignition interlock devices, higher fines, and increased maximum jail terms.

Many people assume that if they blow over the legal limit of .08 that they will not be able to win their DUI case or get the charges reduced to reckless driving.

Individuals with a high blow over 0.15 are even more concerned that their case might be impossible to win.

Keep in mind that the average and median person who submits to a breath test in Florida registers a reading just over .15. That average and median reading has been consistent over time. So blowing over .15 is not uncommon.

Even if you blew over .15, the DUI can be dropped by the prosecutor, dismissed by the judge, or reduced to a less serious charge for all of the reasons discussed in this article.

In addition to hiring an attorney to help you fight the criminal charge in court, you also need an attorney to challenge the administrative suspension of your driver’s license by demanding a FORMAL review hearing within ten (10) days of your arrest.

Click here to read more about our Recent Case Results in DUI Cases.

The breath test instrument used in Florida, the “Intoxilyzer 8000,” is not always accurate or reliable. When the criminal defense can show problems with the breath test, the prosecutor might offer a drastic reduction to avoid a trial.

We created this website to give you some general information. Still, no substitute exists for speaking directly with a criminal defense attorney for advice.

Attorney for the DUI with a BAC over .15 in Tampa, FL

If you were arrested for a DUI with a breath or blood test result showing a breath or blood alcohol level (BAL) reading over .15, contact a criminal defense lawyer at the Sammis Law Firm.

We can discuss the best ways to fight this DUI case during the consultation.

Florida DUI laws provide for enhanced penalties that can be imposed if the readings show that the alcohol concentration was over .15. To avoid those consequences, you might consider entering the Level II RIDR DUI diversion program.

Call us to determine the pros and cons of agreeing to enhanced sanctions and if you are eligible for this program.

Act quickly because you only have ten (10) days after the arrest to have your attorney file a demand for a FORMAL review hearing. We can also secure your 42-day permit so you can keep driving to work, school, and church.

Our attorneys focus on defending individuals charged with drunk driving in Tampa and Plant City for Hillsborough County, Florida.

We also have an office in New Port Richey across from the West Pasco Judicial Center and in Clearwater near the Criminal Justice Center (CJC) courthouse.

Call 813-250-0500.


Information Center


Back to top

Enhanced Penalties for a High DUI Breath Test Reading

Numerous enhanced penalties exist in DUI cases with a reading of .15 or higher on a breath or blood alcohol content test.

In Hillsborough County, the HCSO Arrest Inquiry will list the offense as DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE (OVER 0.15) (TRAF1009).

Under Florida Statute Section 316.193, the Court must impose the following enhanced penalties if the breath test was .15 or over:

  • First DUI Conviction – up to 9 months in jail, a fine of $1,000 to $2,000, and a special condition of probation that you must install an ignition interlock device is required for six (6) months; and
  • Second DUI Conviction – up to 12 months in jail, a fine of $2,000 to $4,000, and a special condition of probation that the ignition interlock device is required for at least 24 months.
  • Third DUI Conviction – up to 12 months in jail, a fine of not less than $4,000.

If you are charged with this type of aggravated DUI, the enhanced penalties might be avoided if the prosecutor agrees and the Court signs a stipulated order.

The order stipulates that the breath or blood alcohol content was less than .15 (notwithstanding the test results in the case), which is the only way to avoid the enhanced sanctions that would otherwise apply.


Back to top

RIDR Program Eligibility

At least in Hillsborough County, FL, if your BAC was over .15 but at least one reading was below .20, you might be eligible for the Level II RIDR diversion program for a first offense.

Under the RIDR program, if you agree to enhanced sanctions, including an ignition interlock device for six (6) months, the state attorney’s office will reduce the DUI to reckless driving with a withhold of adjudication.

For a BAC reading over .15, the RIDR DUI diversion program in Hillsborough County, FL, provides an option for resolving the case. An attorney can help you enter RIDR and complete the sanction.

Not everyone is eligible for a diversion program like RIDR. You are not eligible if you have a prior DUI arrest, were involved in a crash, had a child passenger, or a BAC reading over .20.


Back to top

When One Breath Test Result is Above and One Below 0.15

If there is one reading below .15 reading and one above, the State has failed to meet the burden of proof required for a conviction of DUI with a .15 reading or higher. See Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles v. Colling, 178 So. 3d 2 (Fla. 5th DCA 2014), review denied, 148 So. 3d 770 (Fla. 2014).

In the Colling case, the court concluded that where there were two readings, one below the legal limit and one above, the inference that the petitioner was below the legal limit was equally plausible.

Since the burden was on the Department, it did not meet that burden since one blow was above .08, and one blow was below .08.

The same logic applies when one blow is below .15. Defense attorneys use the Colling case to show why the enhanced penalties should not apply to a situation where one blow is above .15, and the other is below .15.


Back to top

Defenses to the Breath Test DUI Case

Defenses in a breath test DUI case might include:

  • whether the arresting officer failed to watch the defendant during the twenty (20) minute observation period before the breath test;
  • whether the breath test operator and agency inspector were properly certified;
  • whether the particular Intoxilyzer 8000 used in the case was properly maintained after looking at FDLE monthly agency inspection logs, annual inspections, dry-gas standard variances, and slope detector flags on the Intoxilyzer 8000;
  • whether any other explanation other than intoxication can explain the reading; and
  • whether the stop and detention challenges to suppress breath evidence entirely.
  • whether the breath test reading was exaggerated because of GERD, acid reflux, or ketogenic diets (since ketones mimicking isopropyl alcohol)

A DUI defense attorney can audit the breath test machine to determine whether any problems would support a motion to exclude the BAC reading from evidence.

Filing and litigating a motion to exclude the breath test reading often leads to the best results in a DUI with a BAC over .08 or .15.

Click here to read our article about choosing an attorney and how to fight the DUI Breath Test Case.


Back to top

A Stipulation that the DUI BAC was Below .08

If the prosecutor offers to reduce the DUI, the criminal defense attorney must prepare the order for the judge’s signature.

The order is filed in the clerk’s office. A certified copy must be delivered to the Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles (DHSMV) Bureau of Administrative Review (BAR).

After the DHSMV receives the order, the ignition interlock requirement will be deleted.

Many courts use the following type of order to ratify a stipulation between the prosecutor and the criminal defense attorney that the BAC was below .15 for purposes of avoiding the enhanced sanctions or reducing the charge to reckless driving:

ORDER RATIFYING STIPULATION THAT DEFENDANT’S BLOOD ALCOHOL LEVEL WAS LESS THAN .15% AT THE TIME THE DEFENDANT WAS
IN ACTUAL PHYSICAL CONTROL OF A VEHICLE

THIS CAUSE, having come on to be heard before the undersigned on the 3rd day of April, 2023, upon the oral Stipulation by the State of Florida, by and through its Assistant State Attorney, and the Defendant, ________, by and through her counsel of record.

The Court having ratified the Stipulation of the parties, it is ORDERED AND ADJUDGED as follows:

  1. Because of the parties’ stipulation, the Court finds that the Defendant’s blood-alcohol level at the time of arrest was less than .15%.
  2. Because Defendant’s blood-alcohol level was less than .15% at the time of the arrest, the Court will not require that Defendant install the ignition interlock device on her vehicle or require any enhanced fine.

DONE AND ORDERED in chambers in Tampa, Hillsborough County, Florida, this __th day of _____, 2023.

________________________                ________________________
Attorney for the Defendant                               Assistant State Attorney

_________________________

County Court Judge

DHSMV Bureau of Administrative Review (BAR) will automatically flag the driver’s license for an interlock device based on the arrest affidavit unless a certified court order ratifying the stipulation is filed and transmitted to the DHSMV.


How Hillsborough County (RIDR) Compares to Pinellas & Pasco (D.R.O.P.) for Blows Over .15

One of the starkest jurisdictional differences in the Tampa Bay area is how the local State Attorney’s Offices handle first-time DUI diversion when a breath test reading exceeds .15.

A reading that qualifies for diversion in Tampa can completely disqualify you just a few miles away in Clearwater or New Port Richey.

Feature Hillsborough County (13th Circuit)
RIDR Program
Pinellas & Pasco Counties (6th Circuit)
D.R.O.P. Program
Eligibility for BAC > .15 Eligible up to .20 (Level II). If at least one reading is under .20, you can qualify for the program. Strictly Ineligible. Any breath or blood test result exceeding 0.150 is a bright-line disqualifier.
Plea & Disposition DUI reduced to Reckless Driving with a Withhold of Adjudication (no formal conviction). No standard diversion offer. The State will proceed on the enhanced DUI charge under F.S. § 316.193(4).
Probation & Sanctions 12 months probation, 6 months mandatory ignition interlock device (or SCRAM), 75 community service hours, DUI School, and victim impact panel. If convicted at trial or open plea as charged, the court will impose the statutory enhanced DUI sentencing (up to 9 months jail, $1,000–$2,000 fine, mandatory 6-month interlock).

In those cases, your criminal defense attorney will have to help you fight the charges during pretrial motions or at trial if you wish to avoid a DUI conviction.

Record Sealing Potential Eligible to petition to seal the criminal record for the reckless driving charge (since the court will withhold adjudication) upon successful completion of probation (assuming no prior record). Ineligible to seal if convicted of DUI (Florida law strictly prohibits sealing or expunging any DUI conviction).

Because the Sixth Judicial Circuit’s DUI Rehabilitation of Offenders Program (D.R.O.P.) caps eligibility at .150, individuals arrested in Clearwater, St. Petersburg, New Port Richey, or Dade City who blow .151 or higher cannot rely on an administrative diversion track.

In Pinellas and Pasco counties, avoiding the mandatory penalties of an aggravated DUI requires direct courtroom litigation:

  • The Colling Split-Blow Argument: If one breath reading was .152 and the second was .148, your attorney can argue under DHSMV v. Colling that the State cannot prove an alcohol level at or above .15 beyond a reasonable doubt, opening the door to Tier Two D.R.O.P. or an amended charge.
  • Motions to Suppress or Exclude: Filing formal motions to exclude the Intoxilyzer 8000 results based on instrument maintenance irregularities, non-compliance with the 20-minute observation rule, or lack of probable cause for the stop.
  • Individualized Defense Mitigation: Presenting an evidentiary defense packet to the assigned Assistant State Attorney to negotiate a custom reduction to reckless driving outside the rigid confines of standard diversion.

Back to top


 

Additional Resources

Increased Penalties for High Blood Alcohol Content – Visit the website of the NCSL, a national bipartisan organization providing states support and ideas, to learn more about the increased penalties for high blood alcohol content enacted in each state for a high BAC. The article provides an exhaustive list of enhanced penalties for each state.


Back to top

Choosing an Attorney for a DUI BAC over .15 in Tampa, FL

If you have been arrested for DUI with a breath or blood alcohol level over .15, seek out the services of an attorney experienced in fighting the breath test case.

Contact an experienced DUI lawyer with the Sammis Law Firm in Tampa, FL, to discuss the particular facts of your case.

We can help you protect your driving privileges by demanding a FORMAL review hearing.

We can also help you determine if you are eligible for the Level II RIDR Diversion program in Hillsborough County so that you can avoid a DUI conviction altogether.

Call 813-250-0500 for a free consultation today.

Back to top

Free Consultation

Submit this form to request a free and confidential consultation with one of our attorneys.

Our Office Locations
Tampa Office:

Sammis Law Firm, P.A.
1005 N. Marion St.
Tampa, FL 33602
(813) 250-0500

map + directions
New Port Richey Office:

Sammis Law Firm, P.A.
7509 Little Rd.
New Port Richey, FL 34654
(727) 807-6392

map + directions
Clearwater Office:

Sammis Law Firm, P.A.
14010 Roosevelt Blvd. #701
Clearwater, FL 33762
(727) 210-7004

map + directions
Winter Park Office:

Sammis Law Firm, P.A.
1950 Lee Rd Unit 208
Winter Park, FL 32789
(407) 598-9011

map + directions
BBB accredited business rating A+
DUI Defense Lawyers Association - DUIDLA
National College for DUI Defense
National College for DUI Defense state delegate
The Florida Bar Criminal Law Section
NORML Legal Committee - Lifetime Member