The DUI Officer Can’t Hold You Down While They Jab a Needle Into Your Arm (at least not without a warrant)

Missouri v. McNeely has been decided. We can all breath a sigh of relief that the United States Supreme Court has affirmed the judgment of the Missouri Supreme Court. The case holds that in a DUI investigation, “the natural dissipation of alcohol in the bloodstream does not constitute an exigency in every case sufficient to justify conducting a blood test without a warrant.”

Translation: The DUI officer cannot hold you down while they jab a needle into your arm to take your blood by force (at least not without a warrant).

Had the ruling gone the other way, DUI officers might start routinely taking blood by force if the person refused to submit to chemical testing after being arrested for DUI. ACLU’s National Legal Director, Steven R. Shapiro, represented Mr. Tyler McNeely before the Supreme Court. He explained it this way:

We know from experience that drunk-driving laws can be strictly enforced without abandoning constitutional rights. Today’s decision appropriately recognizes what half the states have already demonstrated – that maintaining highway safety does not require sacrificing personal privacy.

The case reminds me of a video made by Justin McShane, a DUI attorney in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. The video shows what happens during a “no refusal” weekend when the arresting officer wanted blood. This is what it looks like when the DUI officer decides to take blood by force:

[youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VRcNN2-eZ7c]

This decision does nothing to prevent the officer from getting a warrant to take blood by force. Fortunately, at least in Florida, DUI officers can NOT get a warrant to take blood after a person suspected of a misdemeanor DUI refuses to submit to chemical testing. The MADD crowd will have to be satisfied with the fact that:

  • the “refusal” can be used against the person at trial; and
  • a second refusal can land the person in jail for 12 months for a separate criminal offense (in addition to the punishment for the DUI charge); and
  • all suspects face a longer administrative suspension of their driver’s license even if they are found not guilty at trial.

The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.

Free Consultation

Submit this form to request a free and confidential consultation with one of our attorneys.

Our Office Locations

Tampa Office:

Sammis Law Firm, P.A.
1005 N. Marion St.
Tampa, FL 33602
(813) 250-0200

map + directions

New Port Richey Office:

Sammis Law Firm, P.A.
7509 Little Rd.
New Port Richey, FL 34654
(727) 807-6392

map + directions

Clearwater Office:

Sammis Law Firm, P.A.
14010 Roosevelt Blvd. #701
Clearwater, FL 33762
(727) 210-7004

map + directions

Client Reviews

The experience I had with Sammis Law firm in May 2022 was exceptional. I was contacted by Joshua M and he was the absolute best at his job and very professional. He kept me informed every step of the way with my case, and he worked hard in getting my charges of domestic assault dismissed. Thank you Joshua and Sammis law group. Their paralegal Danielle was also very amazing.

K. J.

A Google user

google-rating

I am very happy I chose Sammis Law Firm for my case. Dominique is incredibly knowledgeable and was professional in dealing with all parties involved. Her skills played a key role in helping obtain the desired outcome. If you’re looking for an honest and diligent law firm, look no further. You won’t be disappointed!

M.

A Google user

google-rating

Leslie Sammis was extremely professional and provided guidance and support every step of the way. Her knowledge of the law, and her exceptional communication skills, made it easy to navigate the complex legal system. I would highly recommend Leslie to anyone in need of legal services. I couldn’t have done it without you!

R. A.

A Google user

google-rating

First and foremost, I would like to thank God for having both Dominique Celerin and Katherine Aranda represent me in my DUI trial today by being prepared and outstanding attorneys. Dominique Celerin did an amazing job through the whole case, putting my mind at ease and walking me through the whole process all the way. Katherine Aranda did a fabulous job assisting in the trial proceedings. Overall, outstanding job. I would recommend both attorneys for any other case in the near future. Thank you so much from the bottom of my heart for winning this case at trial.

P. K.

A Google user

google-rating

I am so happy I choose Sammis law firm to represent me in my case. I can not thank this firm and Dominique Celerin enough, for helping me through this. I was feeling hopeless when I first reached out and Dominique put me at ease and assured me that she could help. The process was fast! They communicated every step of the way. In the end I am so pleased with the outcome and so grateful for her help!

A. T.

A Google user

google-rating
READ MORE REVIEWS

Our Attorneys

Leslie M. Sammis

Leslie M. Sammis

Jason D. Sammis

Jason D. Sammis

Joshua L. Monteiro

Joshua L. Monteiro

Dominique Celerin

Dominique Celerin

Katherine A. Aranda

Katherine A. Aranda

Idalis Vento

Idalis Vento

BBB accredited business rating A+
DUI Defense Lawyers Association - DUIDLA
National College for DUI Defense
National College for DUI Defense state delegate
The Florida Bar Criminal Law Section
NORML Legal Committee - Lifetime Member