Drivers Leaving the Scene of a Crash – Florida 2014 Senate Bill 102


Leaving the scene of an accident involving a death is already a first-degree felony punishable by up to 30 years in prison, although it carries no minimum mandatory sentence. DUI manslaughter is also a first-degree felony but it carries a mandatory minimum sentence of four years.

The minimum mandatory requirement means that after a conviction for that charge the court must impose that amount of time in prison (as a minimum) although the court can impose up to the statutory maximum. The person must serve that minimum mandatory time day for day in prison (with no gain time or potential for early release).

As a criminal defense attorney in Tampa that represents clients charged with different versions of Florida’s leaving the scene statutes (often called “hit and run”), I would argue that the lack of a minimum mandatory penalty in Florida’s statute does NOT lead to more people fleeing the scene after a car crash.

Changing the law isn’t going to lower the number of these cases. Instead, it will create more injustice as courts must impose the “minimum mandatory” sentences instead of a fair sentence based on the facts of the case.

Enhancing the Penalties for Leaving the Scene

In a recent article in the Tampa Bay Times, “As hit and run cases multiply is Florida law to blame?“, reporter John Romano poses the question this way:

Do you know what you call that? An incentive to flee, no matter how many broken or dying bodies you leave behind. Even nonfatal accidents reward hit-and-run drivers with similar or lesser penalties than those convicted of DUI.

When you think of it that way, the only reason for an impaired driver to stick around is his/her own sense of compassion and responsibility for the carnage they have created.

That’s not exactly true. If only non-serious injuries occur then remaining at the scene might mean an arrest for “DUI with non-serious bodily injury” which is a misdemeanor in Florida. On the other hand, “leaving the scene with non-serious bodily injury” is a third degree felony which is much worse.

Also, many people get caught by a law enforcement officer while they are driving away from the scene. For those individuals, the penalties are certainly more serious because the individual could face the leaving the scene charges and the DUI related charges.

Nevertheless, the idea that someone might get away with something by leaving the scene is often true. In many of these hit and run cases, no one can identify the driver. Unless someone gets a clear view of the person driving and writes down the tag number, there is usually little other evidence. Even when a witness can identify the driver, unless the investigating officer gets a full confession from the driver, these cases are difficult to prosecute.

If the driver waits 12 hours, then retains an attorney and invokes his right to remain silent and to have an attorney present for questioning, then as a practical matter – there is little chance of being charged with a DUI related offense.

Without the confession, the chances for a leaving the scene prosecution also decrease dramatically. Investigators focus their resources on the cases involving death or serious bodily injury and the rest often go unsolved. For law enforcement officers – these cases must be extremely frustrating and take up tremendous resources.

Hit and Run Cases Are Up in Florida

According to the Florida Highway Patrol, the number of hit and run crashes is up. According to the FHP “hit and run” page on their website:

  • Hit-and-run crashes involving fatalities increased from 162 in 2011 to 168 in 2012.
  • The number of hit-and-run crashes statewide equaled 69,994 in 2012.
  • Three out of every five fatalities in 2012 were pedestrians struck in hit-and-run crashes.

FHP’s crime statistics estimate that in Hillsborough County, Pinellas County and Pasco County combined, more than 8,000 of these hit and run cases occurred last year. Although most involve only minor property damage.

Florida State Senator, Miguel Diaz de la Portilla, R-Miami, wants to increase the penalties in Florida’s hit-and-run statute, Florida Statute Section 316.027. He has introduced Senate Bill 102. It turns any hit and run conviction involving even non-serious injury into a felony offense with at least a four year minimum mandatory prison sentence. Even if it were proven that the person was not DUI and that leaving the scene did not contribute to any delay in the victim receiving medical treatment, it still would require a four year min man.

In fact, it imposes these new minimum mandatory penalties –

  • a four (4) year minimum mandatory provision if any non-serious personal injury occurs;
  • a seven (7) year minimum mandatory provision for any serious injury; and
  • a ten (10) year minimum mandatory provision if a death occurs after the crash.

Florida 2014 Senate Bill 102 (to be known as the “Aaron Cohen Life Protection Act“) enhances penalties for drivers leaving the scene of a crash.

Other Florida Statutes for Leaving the Scene of a Crash

For misdemeanor offenses, Florida law provides for two different statues when the hit and run results in only property damage with no injury to any person.

  • Florida Statute Section 316.063 – makes it a second degree misdemeanor (punishable by up to 60 days in jail and a $500 fine) to leave the scene of a crash involving only damage to unattended property. The driver of a vehicle that is involved in a crash causing damage to unattended property must leave a visible note with his name, address, and registration information. The driver must also notify law enforcement of the crash.
  • Florida Statute Section 316.061 – makes it a second degree misdemeanor (punishable by up to 60 days in jail and a $500 fine) to leave the scene of a crash involving an occupied vehicle or attended property. Instead, the driver must remain at the scene to provide pertinent information such as the driver’s name, address, and registration. The driver must present his driver’s license if requested and notify law enforcement of the accident.

Does a person who makes that split second decision to leave the scene after a crash really contemplate these nuances in Florida’s statutory scheme? Probably not.

The new proposed law for hit and run cases in Florida just takes away the judge’s discretion to fashion a just sentence based on the facts of the case.

Don’t Drink and Drive

I’ve often heard friends talk about driving after having a few drinks. People rationalize their decisions in all kinds of ways. They take the chance because the worse thing they can imagine is getting arrested for DUI. But as a criminal defense attorney, I’ve seen the consequences of having a few drinks and then getting into a crash. Even if your intoxication didn’t cause the crash, you can still be held criminal liable for what would otherwise be a tragic accident.

On average, after a DUI crash involving the death of another person – a prison sentence of 7 to 15 years is the most expected outcome. For me, that is the most persuasive reason to just never drive after having consumed any alcohol. It doesn’t matter that I think I could drive home safely, it just matters that an accusation could be made against me under those circumstances regardless of whether I was actually impaired or not. When you understand how the system really works – it is a much easier decision not to drink and drive.

The Philosophical Question

In the newspaper article cited above, the Pasco County Sheriff Chris Nocco is quoted saying:

“The way it stands now it’s like a college class where they pose philosophical questions: If you are driving under the influence and facing however-many-years in prison, would you stop and make a phone call to help a person you just hit, who may be dying in the road? Basically, are you more worried about that person’s survival, or your own well-being?”

That question assumes that no one else is around to call 911 after the crash. In many of these cases, other people immediately call 911 before the driver even makes that split second decision to leave the scene. In other words, what if you know that leaving the scene isn’t going to make a difference in whether the injured person receives emergency medical attention?

The statute doesn’t make any distinction between leaving the scene when other people are around to call 911 or not. The intention to abandon the victim so the victim does not receive medical attention is not an element of the offense. So many of these cases involve leaving the scene after the driver realizes that someone else has already called 911. Does your answer change under those circumstances?

Here is a more interesting question:

What if you go home after the crash. After leaving the scene you read online about the new minimum mandatory penalties for hit and run. You learn that you are facing at least a four year prison sentence – to be served in Florida State prison – day for day – even if the other person involved in the crash suffered only a non-serious injury. Do you call the police to report what happened and incriminate yourself?


The Statutory Language of the Proposed New “Leaving the Scene of a Crash” Statute

The statutory language of Senate Bill 102 is provided, in part, below:

       Florida Senate - 2014                              CS for SB 102

       By the Committee on Transportation; and Senators Diaz de la
       Portilla, Garcia, and Evers

       596-00986-14                                           2014102c1
    1                        A bill to be entitled
    2         An act relating to drivers leaving the scene of a
    3         crash; creating the “Aaron Cohen Life Protection Act”;
    4         amending s. 316.027, F.S.; redefining the term
    5         “serious bodily injury” and defining the term
    6         “vulnerable road user”; requiring the driver of a
    7         vehicle involved in a crash that results in serious
    8         bodily injury to a person to immediately stop the
    9         vehicle and remain at the scene of the crash;
   10         providing that a person commits a felony of the second
   11         degree if he or she fails to stop the vehicle and
   12         remain at the scene of the crash until specified
   13         requirements are fulfilled; requiring the court to
   14         impose a mandatory minimum term of imprisonment under
   15         certain circumstances; requiring the revocation of the
   16         driver’s driver license; requiring the driver to
   17         participate in specified programs; providing for
   18         ranking of an offense committed if the victim of the
   19         offense was a vulnerable road user; authorizing the
   20         defendant to move to depart from the mandatory minimum
   21         term of imprisonment under certain circumstances;
   22         providing requirements and procedures for such
   23         departure; amending s. 322.0261, F.S.; requiring the
   24         Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles to
   25         include in the curriculum of a certain driver
   26         improvement course instruction addressing the rights
   27         of vulnerable road users; amending s. 322.28, F.S.;
   28         requiring the court to revoke for at least 3 years the
   29         driver license of a person convicted of leaving the
   30         scene of a crash involving injury, serious bodily
   31         injury, or death; reenacting and amending s.
   32         322.34(6), F.S., relating to driving while a driver
   33         license is suspended, revoked, canceled, or
   34         disqualified, to incorporate the amendment to s.
   35         322.28, F.S., in a reference thereto; amending s.
   36         921.0022, F.S.; revising the offense severity ranking
   37         chart; conforming a cross-reference; providing an
   38         effective date.
   40  Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:
   42         Section 1. This act may be cited as the “Aaron Cohen Life
   43  Protection Act.”
   44         Section 2. Section 316.027, Florida Statutes, is amended to
   45  read:
   46         316.027 Crash involving death or personal injuries.—
   47         (1) As used in this section, the term:
   48         (a) “Serious bodily injury” means an injury to a person,
   49  including the driver, which consists of a physical condition
   50  that creates a substantial risk of death, serious personal
   51  disfigurement, or protracted loss or impairment of the function
   52  of a bodily member or organ.
   53         (b) Vulnerable road user” means:
   54         1. A pedestrian, including a person actually engaged in
   55  work upon a highway, or in work upon utility facilities along a
   56  highway, or engaged in the provision of emergency services
   57  within the right-of-way;
   58         2. A person operating a bicycle, motorcycle, scooter, or
   59  moped lawfully on the roadway;
   60         3. A person riding an animal; or
   61         4. A person lawfully operating on a public right-of-way,
   62  crosswalk, or shoulder of the roadway:
   63         a. A farm tractor or similar vehicle designed primarily for
   64  farm use;
   65         b. A skateboard, roller skates,or in-line skates;
   66         c. A horse-drawn carriage;
   67         d. An electric personal assistive mobility device; or
   68         e. A wheelchair.
   69         (2)(1)(a) The driver of a any vehicle involved in a crash
   70  occurring on public or private property which that results in
   71  injury to a of any person other than serious bodily injury shall
   72  must immediately stop the vehicle at the scene of the crash, or
   73  as close thereto as possible, and shall must remain at the scene
   74  of the crash until he or she has fulfilled the requirements of
   75  s. 316.062. A Any person who willfully violates this paragraph
   76  commits a felony of the third degree, punishable as provided in
   77  s. 775.082, s. 775.083, or s. 775.084.
   78         (b)The driver of a vehicle involved in a crash occurring
   79  on public or private property which results in serious bodily
   80  injuryto a person shall immediately stop the vehicle at the
   81  scene of the crash, or as close thereto as possible, and shall
   82  remain at the scene of the crash until he or she has fulfilled
   83  the requirements of s. 316.062.A person who willfully violates
   84  this paragraph commits a felony of the second degree, punishable
   85  as provided in s. 775.082, s. 775.083, or s. 775.084.
   86         (c)(b) The driver of a any vehicle involved in a crash
   87  occurring on public or private property which that results in
   88  the death of a any person shall must immediately stop the
   89  vehicle at the scene of the crash, or as close thereto as
   90  possible, and shall must remain at the scene of the crash until
   91  he or she has fulfilled the requirements of s. 316.062. A person
   92  who is arrested for a violation of this paragraph and who has
   93  previously been convicted of a violation of this section, s.
   94  316.061, s. 316.191, or s. 316.193, or a felony violation of s.
   95  322.34, shall be held in custody until brought before the court
   96  for admittance to bail in accordance with chapter 903. A Any
   97  person who willfully violates this paragraph commits a felony of
   98  the first degree, punishable as provided in s. 775.082, s.
   99  775.083, or s. 775.084, and shall be sentenced to a mandatory
  100  minimum term of imprisonment of 4 years. A Any person who
  101  willfully commits such a violation while driving under the
  102  influence as set forth in s. 316.193(1) shall be sentenced to a
  103  mandatory minimum term of imprisonment of 4 2 years.
  104         (d)(c) Notwithstanding s. 775.089(1)(a), if the driver of a
  105  vehicle violates paragraph (a), or paragraph (b), or paragraph
  106  (c), the court shall order the driver to make restitution to the
  107  victim for any damage or loss unless the court finds clear and
  108  compelling reasons not to order the restitution. Restitution may
  109  be monetary or nonmonetary restitution. The court shall make the
  110  payment of restitution a condition of probation in accordance
  111  with s. 948.03. An order requiring the defendant to make
  112  restitution to a victim does not remove or diminish the
  113  requirement that the court order payment to the Crimes
  114  Compensation Trust Fund under chapter 960. Payment of an award
  115  by the Crimes Compensation Trust Fund creates an order of
  116  restitution to the Crimes Compensation Trust Fund unless
  117  specifically waived in accordance with s. 775.089(1)(b).
  118         (e)A driver who violates paragraph (a), paragraph (b), or
  119  paragraph (c) shall:
  120         1.Have his or her driver license revoked for at least 3
  121  years as provided in s. 322.28(4);
  122         2.Participate in a victim’s impact panel session in a
  123  judicial circuit if such a panel exists; or
  124         3. Participate in a driver education course relating to the
  125  rights of vulnerable road users relative to vehicles on the
  126  roadway.
  127         (f) For purposes of sentencing under chapter 921 and
  128  determining incentive gain-time eligibility under chapter 944,
  129  an offense listed in this subsection is ranked one level above
  130  the ranking specified in s. 921.0022 or s. 921.0023 for the
  131  offense committed if the victim of the offense was a vulnerable
  132  road user.
  133         (g) The defendant may move to depart from the mandatory
  134  minimum term of imprisonment prescribed in paragraph (c) unless
  135  the violation was committed while the defendant was driving
  136  under the influence. The state may object to this departure. The
  137  court may grant the motion only if it finds that a factor,
  138  consideration, or circumstance clearly demonstrates that
  139  imposing a mandatory minimum term of imprisonment would
  140  constitute or result in an injustice. The court shall state in
  141  open court the basis for granting the motion.
  142         (2) The department shall revoke the driver’s license of the
  143  person so convicted.
  144         (3) The stops shall Every stop must be made without
  145  unnecessarily obstructing traffic more than is necessary, and,
  146  if a damaged vehicle is obstructing traffic, the driver of the
  147  vehicle shall must make every reasonable effort to move the
  148  vehicle or have it moved so as not to obstruct the regular flow
  149  of traffic. A Any person who fails to comply with this
  150  subsection shall be cited for a nonmoving violation, punishable
  151  as provided in chapter 318.
  152         (4) In addition to any other civil, criminal, or
  153  administrative penalty imposed, a person whose commission of a
  154  noncriminal traffic infraction or a any violation of this
  155  chapter or s. 1006.66 causes or results in the death of another
  156  person may, in addition to any other civil, criminal, or
  157  administrative penalty imposed, be required by the court to
  158  serve 120 community service hours in a trauma center or hospital
  159  that regularly receives victims of vehicle accidents, under the
  160  supervision of a registered nurse, an emergency room physician,
  161  or an emergency medical technician pursuant to a voluntary
  162  community service program operated by the trauma center or
  163  hospital.
  164         (5) This section does not apply to crashes occurring during
  165  a motorsports event, as defined in s. 549.10(1), or at a closed
  166  course motorsport facility, as defined in s. 549.09(1).
  167         Section 3. Subsection (2) of section 322.0261, Florida
  168  Statutes, is amended to read...
  200         (b)Upon a conviction for a violation of s. 316.027(2)(a),
  201  s. 316.027(2)(b), or s. 316.027(2)(c) involving injury, serious
  202  bodily injury, or death, the court shall revoke the driver
  203  license of the person convicted for a minimum period of 3 years....
  229         921.0022 Criminal Punishment Code; offense severity ranking
  230  chart.—
  232         (e) LEVEL 5
  345         (g) LEVEL 7
  348  Florida Statute               Felony Degree       Description

  473         Section 7. This act shall take effect July 1, 2014.

Leslie Sammis is an attorney representing clients with DUI and hit and run (leaving the scene) throughout Tampa and Hillsborough County, FL, and the surrounding counties of Pinellas County, Pasco County and Polk County, FL.

Free Consultation

Submit this form to request a free and confidential consultation with one of our attorneys.

Our Office Locations

Tampa Office:

Sammis Law Firm, P.A.
1005 N. Marion St.
Tampa, FL 33602
(813) 250-0200

map + directions

New Port Richey Office:

Sammis Law Firm, P.A.
7509 Little Rd.
New Port Richey, FL 34654
(727) 807-6392

map + directions

Clearwater Office:

Sammis Law Firm, P.A.
14010 Roosevelt Blvd. #701
Clearwater, FL 33762
(727) 210-7004

map + directions

Our Attorneys

Leslie M. Sammis

Leslie M. Sammis

Jason D. Sammis

Jason D. Sammis

Joshua L. Monteiro

Joshua L. Monteiro

Dominique Celerin

Dominique Celerin

Katherine A. Aranda

Katherine A. Aranda

Idalis Vento

Idalis Vento